Top Rated Restaurants Near Shelter Island

35 Governor Winthrop Blvd. , New London CT

23.53 miles

10095 Main Rd Unit 8 , Mattituck NY

12.33 miles

208 Bank St , New London CT

23.29 miles

11 E Pattagansett Rd , Niantic CT

19.12 miles

62 Jobs Ln , Southampton NY

12.84 miles

212 Front Street , Greenport NY

3.37 miles

106 Boston Post Rd Ste D, Waterford CT

21.96 miles

90 Truman St , New London CT

23.11 miles

7 S. Main St , Westbrook CT

16.77 miles

527 Long Hill Rd , Center Groton CT

24.38 miles

435 E Lake Dr, Montauk NY

20.78 miles

11 Commerce Ave, Riverhead NY

21.72 miles